Medicare patients given fewer treatment options
Patient Access Weekly Advisor, March 7, 2012
More than one-third of Medicare patients who underwent a prostatectomy, and 90% who had elective insertion of a coronary stent, said their physicians gave them no advance information about more conservative options that produce similar survival outcomes, says a survey conducted by the Dartmouth Institute’s Informed Medical Decisions Foundation.
The results indicate that rather than guide patients to thoughtfully consider alternatives, physicians are still paternalistically making those decisions for their patients—without discussion—on grounds that they think they know what’s best for their patients, says principal investigator Floyd J. Fowler.
“There’s a big tradition of physicians taking responsibility, and being paternalistic when these decisions are made,” Fowler says. “I won’t argue that they weren’t trying to be beneficent when they made these decisions, but we think this is not the way decisions like this should be made,” especially when the invasive procedures in question carry considerable risks and side-effects.
The paper by Fowler and colleagues is published in the March 2 issue of the Journal of General Internal Medicine.
Read more on HealthLeaders Media.
- Differentiate between types of wound debridement
- CMS seeks comment on quality measures
- Note similarities and differences between HCPCS, CPT® codes
- OB services: Coding inside and outside of the package
- ICD-10-CM coma, stroke codes require more specific documentation
- Complications from immobility by body system
- Fracture coding in ICD-10-CM requires greater specificity
- Weekly roundup
- What does case-mix index mean to you?
- Hospital offers incentives for identifying incorrect patient status
- More new physicians taking advantage of debt forgiveness program
- Medical school awards scholarships to delay student enrollment
- Three ways to safely handle, track returned meds
- Q&A: Code assignment for hospital acquired/healthcare associated conditions
- New malnutrition criteria could help ensure consistent coding
- Learn how to hold staff accountable in a nonpunitive culture
- Joint Commission to make antibiotic stewardship mandatory by 2017
- Inpatient-only procedures: Accuracy helps avoid denials, ensure compliance
- How to report ultrasound with ultrasound guided biopsy of thyroid
- Bill and charge for supplies correctly to reduce risk and minimize lost revenue