Nursing

Web site spotlight: Nurse sues hospital after allegedly being forced to assist in abortion

Nurse Leader Insider, August 10, 2009

Want to receive articles like this one in your inbox? Subscribe to Nurse Leader Insider!

A New York City nurse slapped a lawsuit on her hospital after allegedly being forced to assist in a late-term abortion that defied her religious beliefs.

Catherina Cenzon-DeCarlo, a devout Catholic operating room nurse employed at Mount Sinai Hospital, claims she had to compromise her faith and perform the procedure on a 22-week pregnant patient or risk losing her job and her license. She says the hospital has known of her objections to participating in abortions since she interviewed for her position in 2004. But Cenzon-DeCarlo accuses supervisors of refusing to assign the procedure to another nurse when she begged them to.

Cenzon-DeCarlo says her involvement in the May 24 abortion has left her with nightmares that prevent her from sleeping, reports the New York Post.

The incident is alarming to some of the most seasoned nurses in the field.

“Ms. Cenzon-DeCarlo has experienced employer bullying at its finest,” says Deanna Miller, RN, MSN, Ed, HCE, manager of critical care and staff development at University Hospitals Geneva (OH) Medical Center. “During my 22 years in healthcare, I have never witnessed or experienced this type of infringement on a clinician’s rights. If Mount Sinai was aware of [her] beliefs, she should never have been put into such an emotionally taxing position.”

The abortion was performed on a patient with preeclampsia—a condition characterized by high blood pressure that can result in seizures or death if left untreated. However, the suit filed last week alleges Mount Sinai supervisors embellished the patient’s condition and told Cenzon-DeCarlo that the mother may die if she did not assist with the abortion. The nurse claims she later found out hospital records stated the abortion was a “Category II” procedure, which is not immediately life threatening.

Editor’s note: This excerpt was adapted from the article, “Nurse sues hospital after allegedly being forced to assist in abortion” featured in The Reading Room on HCPro’s online resource center, www.StrategiesforNurseManagers.com.

Do you need continuing education (CE) credits? Check out this month’s CE article to learn about effective checklists used in various hospital settings or visit our archives and view a compilation of CE articles (marked with an asterisk).



Want to receive articles like this one in your inbox? Subscribe to Nurse Leader Insider!

Most Popular